Voice concerns over Exide’s Mill River plan

The leadership of Nutmeg TU 217 is urging members to send letters to state, local and federal officials expressing concerns about Exide’s plan to remove lead from the Mill River.

An earlier version of this story incorrectly included the word “oppose.”

TU has joined other residents and conservationists in raising questions about a plan they say has too few specifics and too many risks.

The letter can be copied in its entirety from nutmegtrout.org, pasted into an email and email to officials. Email addresses are provide with the online story.

Links to articles about the plan can be found HERE.

After a subsequent meeting of the Fairfield Conservation Commission, the Fairfield Citizen reported  that the commission focused on “Exide’s proposal to discharge sediment-cleansed water back into Mill River during the dredging operation — because the deadline for public comment on that application is Feb. 7.”

The letter appears below, with email addresses for state officials. Copy the text, paste it into an email, personalize it and send it to those officials.

—————

 

Dear ______________,

 

I am writing to ask your consideration, in your position as ___________________, of my concerns about the proposed Exide Mill River Remediation Action Plan and its significant deficiencies as an adequate restoration program for the damage this river has suffered.  As a member of Trout Unlimited’s local Nutmeg Chapter in whose geographic area the Mill River flows, please allow me to express my views by reiterating below our Chapter’s position, representing our almost four hundred members residing in Fairfield and surrounding towns, which succinctly reflects the serious shortfalls of the Plan, and therefore my strong concerns about it.

Trout Unlimited’s mission is to conserve, protect and restore coldwater fisheries and their watersheds. As such, we have been following Exide’s reme diati on effort with great interest for many years. We are encouraged to see a Remedial Action Plan come together, but we do have some substantial concerns that echo those expressed by the Town of Fairfield’s Conservation Department among others.

 

First, we question the wisdom of any Remedial Action Plan for lead impacted river sediment that does not include a comparable action plan for chromium impacted river sediment. Second, we do not believe Exide has done enough to evaluate and explain the environmental risks potentially associated with in-water dredging activity during the spawning season. Third, this plan does not address the need for a fish passage as an essential component of remediation. Fourth, no provision of public access is addressed. Lastly, we have yet to see any plan to restore the river to its natural state once the dredging is complete. A true remediation effort would include re-filling the dredged holes with clean soil, restoring the river bottom with structural habitat including rocks and logs and finally, re-planting the river banks with native plant species.

 

Related to these concerns and warranting specific attention is the issue of the river herring run (alewives and blueback.) NOAA is considering these species for endangered species status. Exide is saying that their dredging process poses no issue to the spawning of these fish because the slurry will be contained and therefore they should be allowed to dredge during the spring spawning season. However, based on the technique used in 1983 — cutterhead dredge and floating silt curtain — which seems to be much the same as the one proposed now, there was plenty of spillover which moved lead all over the river. Certainly this will seriously jeopardize successful river herring spawning.

 

Ms./Mr. ____________, the Mill River is one of Fairfield County’s natural treasures. It is one of only a handful of specially designated Class One Wild Trout Streams in Connecticut. It’s estuarial confluence with Long Island Sound could, with an adequate restoration plan, once again be a healthy environment for our unique natural treasures (and economic resources) such as sea-run brown trout, and for safe use and enjoyment by residents of Fairfield and adjacent towns. This is finally the moment for a prudent plan to correct the damage to the Mill and restore its health and value to all of us.

 

Thank you for considering my views on this very important issue.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

—————————

 

The letter should be sent to:

DEEP Commissioner Daniel C. Esty

deep.webmaster@ct.gov

State Rep. Kim Fawcett

Kim.Fawcett@cga.ct.gov

State Sen. John McKinney

John.McKinney@cga.ct.gov

State Rep. Tony Hwang

Tony.Hwang@cga.ct.gov

State Rep. Brenda Kupchick

brenda.kupchick@housegop.ct.gov

Those in other towns may also send to their legislators.

Scouts take a break during a cleanup of the Halfway River in spring of 2012. Eric Rasmussen, who coordinated his effort with Nutmeg TU, earned his Eagle Award for his work.

Scout earns Eagle rank for river cleanup

Scouts take a break during a cleanup of the Halfway River in spring of 2012. Eric Rasmussen, who coordinated his effort with Nutmeg TU, earned his Eagle Award for his work.

Eric Rasmussen, who led a cleanup of the Halfway River on the Monroe/Newtown border last spring, will receive his Eagle Scout award Saturday, Jan. 26, at 2 p.m. at Fairfield Ludlowe High School.

Six members of Boy Scout Troop 199 in Fairfield will be elevated to the rank of Eagle Scout that day. Michael Connelly, William Fulda, Conor McGuinness, Michael McQuade and William Poling will also be awarded their certificates at the Eagle Court of Honor ceremony on

Eric RasmussenEric, son of Jarry and Terri Rasmussen, is a junior at Fairfield Ludlowe High School. He worked with Trout Unlimited to clean up a section of Halfway River polluted with junked cars, appliances, water heaters and household trash. Volunteers for this project included family, friends, scouts and members of Trout Unlimited, who hauled the garbage up a steep hill to a container provided by City Carting.

City Carting also donated all the proceeds from the scrap metal back to Troop 199.

Eric has held numerous positions in Troop 199, including assistant senior patrol leader, patrol leader and scribe. He attended the National Boy Scout Jamboree in 2010. Eric was elected to The Order of the Arrow and participated in the Thunderbird Youth Leadership Training.

Eric is a long-distance swimmer on the Fairfield High School co-op swim team. He is also a member of the Key Club. He has been a member of the Fairfield YMCA FlyFins Swim Team for 10 years. For the past two summers, Eric worked as a lifeguard for the Lake Hills Beach Association.

Eric traveled to China last spring with his foreign language class.

 

Nutmeg TU Banquet March 23

Nutmeg TU will hold its 36th annual banquet Saturday, March 23, at the Restaurant at Tashua Knolls Golf Course in Trumbull.

Doors open at 6:30 p.m., with an open bar till 7:30 p.m.

The evening will include a door prize, raffles, a silent auction and presentations on Nutmeg TU activities.

Donations of prizes are still needed. To donate a prize or volunteer to help with the banquet, contact Banquet Chairman Chuck MacMath at cmacmath59@yahoo.com.

Click to download a printable reservation form, to be printed and returned to the address on it by March 15.

Click here for directions to the restaurant.

 

Beneath the surface of the lower Mill River lies lead and other waste from the former Exide battery plant. The company has announced a plan to clean the river, but some neighbors and conservationists fear what the work could stir up. (Fairfield Sun/Shawn O'Sullivan)

Exide cleanup plan raises questions

Beneath the surface of the lower Mill River lies lead and other waste from the former Exide battery plant. The company has announced a plan to clean the river, but some neighbors and conservationists fear what the work could stir up. (Fairfield Sun/Shawn O'Sullivan)

The state Department of Environmental Protection has extended the deadline for comment on a proposal by Exide to dredge the lower Mill River in an effort to remove lead contamination left by the company’s battery making operation.

The extension comes after a hearing at which questions were raised by residents and conservations, including Nutmeg TU representatives.

Nutmeg TU President Chuck Petruccelli told The Fairfield Sun that the chapter’s members are being encouraged to express opposition to Exide’s plan.

The Sun’s article also included views of the proposal from Nutmeg TU’s conservation chairman.

“Trout Unlimited’s mission is to conserve, protect and restore coldwater fisheries and their watersheds. As such, we have been following Exide’s remediation effort with great interest for many years,” said Ross Ogden, conservation chairman for Nutmeg TU Chapter 217. “We are encouraged to see a Remedial Action Plan come together, but we do have some substantial concerns that echo those expressed by the town of Fairfield’s Conservation Department, among others. First, we question the wisdom of any Remedial Action Plan for lead-impacted river sediment that does not include a comparable action plan for chromium-impacted river sediment. Second, we do not believe Exide has done enough to evaluate and explain the environmental risks potentially associated with in-water dredging activity during the spawning season. Lastly, we have yet to see any plan to restore the river to its natural state once the dredging is complete. A true remediation effort would include refilling the dredged holes with clean soil, restoring the river bottom with structural habitat, including rock and logs, and finally, replanting the river banks with native plant species.”

A Connecticut Post report also quoted residents questioning the proposal. One asked if the river itself is deep enough for the dredging proposed by Exide.

After a subsequent meeting of the Fairfield Conservation Commission, the Fairfield Citizen reported  that the commission focused on “Exide’s proposal to discharge sediment-cleansed water back into Mill River during the dredging operation — because the deadline for public comment on that application is Feb. 7.”

More details and links will be posted as the story develops.

Proposed substation could affect Far Mill River

A roughly $38-million plan for a new United Illuminating substation in Shelton has been proposed by the power company, and construction could start in July if the proposal receives state approval.

The Connecticut Siting Council has scheduled public hearings on the application this Thursday, Jan. 17, at 3 p.m. and  7 p.m. at Shelton City Hall.

The substation would take up roughly two acres of a six-acre site at 14 Old Stratford Road. The six-acre property has Route 8 to the east, Pootatuck Place on its western side, and to the north, Far Mill River. Until the 1990s it was used by the Lord Corp. for the manufacture of O-rings and seals, according to UI.

Click here to read coverage in The Shelton Herald.

Yates to explain winter fly fishing

YATES-ICE-JAN-2013

Guide, author and Trout Unlimited leader Jeff Yates will describe how to safely and comfortably enjoy fly fishing during the winter at the next regular meeting of the Nutmeg Chapter of Trout Unlimited.

YATES-JAN-2013-WALKINGThe meeting will be held Monday, Jan. 21, 7-9 p.m., at Burroughs Community Center, 2470 Fairfield Ave. in Black Rock.

President of the Mianus Chapter of Trout Unlimited, board member of Friends of Mianus River Park, life member of Trout Unlimited and the Housatonic Fly Fishers Association, Jeff is also a member of the American Museum of Fly Fishing and the Catskills Fly Fishing Center and Museum. When he’s not guiding or fishing, Yates is leading river restoration projects or planning fishing and conservation events and clinics.

Information can be found at www.flyfishingct.com, or on Twitter and Facebook.

Next meeting Jan. 21 at new site

TU-BCCThe January meeting of Nutmeg TU Chapter 217 will be held Monday, Jan. 21, at Burroughs Community Center, 2470 Fairfield Ave. in Black Rock. The center is less than ¾ of a mile from Fayerweather Yacht Club, also in Black Rock.

Entrances to Burroughs Community Center are located off Fairfield Avenue and Ellsworth Street. Off-street parking, illuminated and monitored by video, is available.

The meeting will be held in the lower level of Burroughs Community Center.

As Jan. 21 is Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day, time will be taken to honor and reflect upon Dr. King’s life and work.

Permanent sites for board and regular meetings is being sought, and feedback about holding future meetings at Burroughs Community Center is needed from members to help in that selection.

Meeting on Exide cleanup Jan. 10

The Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection will hold a public session on Exide’s latest plans to remediate the lower Mill River Thursday, Jan. 10, at 7 p.m. at Fairfield Ludlowe High School, 785 Unquowa Road, Fairfield.

The plan by the battery maker that once operated on the Post Road is the result of 30 years of negotiations with the state and town on how to clean the site. Click here to download a town review of the proposal.

Nutmeg TU is concerned about the effects the cleanup could have on the river, its’ wildlife and its ongoing Mill River Improvement Project.

Exide proposes dredging the sediment from the bottom of the river. According to a review of the plan by Fairfield officials, that could stir up contaminants in the river.

The Exide plan also would not address contamination caused by a plating company still in operation on side of the Mill River opposite the former Exide site.

Ron Merly and Ross Ogden of Nutmeg TU have met with Fairfield conservation officials, and Merly told the board of directors Dec. 6 that the plans are “very vague.”

One current proposal, Merly said, would begin work during the annual Herring migration up the Mill River.

Nutmegtrout.org will be updated with coverage of the hearing.

Men charged in Saugatuck oil spill

Weston police arrested two Stamford men for stealing copper piping from a house and in the process causing an oil spill in the Saugatuck River, according to The Weston Forum.

Police told The Weston Forum that the Weston Fire Department received a call on Friday, Dec. 28, from a resident on Valley Forge Road who complained about the smell of “gas.” When the Fire Department arrived, firefighters saw two men loading copper pipes into a vehicle from a house across the street at 153 Valley Forge Road.

Police were called to the scene and found two men stealing items from the house, including copper piping.

“Investigators say 37-year-old Jose Morales and his brother, 42-year-old Mauro Morales, stole copper piping from a home at 153 Valley Forge Road, inadvertently contaminating the Saugatuck River after they accidentally severed an oil line,” according to a report at connecticut.news12.com.

The men had apparently cut copper pipes in the basement that led to a fuel oil line, causing oil to leak into a drain that went under the road and into the Saugatuck River, according to The Weston Forum. The fuel oil caused the smell the neighbor complained about.

Police called the state Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) for remediation and the oil was cleaned from the Saugatuck, the Forum reported.

“The Saugatuck River is known for its trout population, which experts say is among the healthiest in the country,” according to the News12 report.

José Morales and Mauro Morales were arrested at the scene and charged them with burglary, possession of burglary tools, criminal mischief, larceny in the third degree, conspiracy, and violation of water pollution control requirements. They have a Jan. 7 court date.

More time to submit comment on UConn water plan

UPDATE JAN 4, 8:30 a.m.: The window for public comment on Environmental Impact Evaluation for the proposals for the water supply to UCONN and Mansfield has been extended to Thursday, Jan. 31.

Nutmeg TU learned of the extension shortly after posting a story and alerting members on Thursday, Jan. 3.

Farmington Valley TU President Bill Case said a hearing will be held in the Farmington Valley as well.

Comments already submitted may be revised until Jan. 31, Case added.

JAN. 3, 8:50 p.m.: Public comment on the Environmental Impact Evaluation for the proposals for the water supply to UCONN and Mansfield are due Friday, Jan. 4.

“Unfortunately, as of this time and regardless of pleas from many organizations, the date has not been extended,” according to the Farmington Valley TU newsletter, Riffles and Runs.

Nutmeg Chapter members are asked to weigh in on the proposal.

Farmington Valley TU President Bill Case has prepared talking points opposed to the proposal, viewable at http://fvtu.org.

Comments should be addressed to:

Mr. Jason M. Coite

University of Connecticut – Office of Environmental Policy

31 LeDoyt Road, U-3055

Storrs, CT  06269-3055

Phone 860-486-9305

Fax 860-486-5477 .

Jason.coite@uconn.edu

Articles on the proposal can be read at the following links:

http://newhartfordplus.com/2012/12/29/mdc-vies-to-meet-uconns-water-needs

http://www.courant.com/community/mansfield/hc-mansfield-storrs-water-1212-20121211,0,7182350.story

http://www.courant.com/community/canton/hc-canton-farmington-river-1214-20121213,0,4504595.story

http://www.courant.com/news/connecticut/hc-mdc-uconn-watershed-20121213,0,765866.story

http://www.courant.com/news/connecticut/hc-mdc-uconn-water-plan-20121221,0,5820156.story

http://www.registercitizen.com/articles/2012/12/29/news/doc50dfd3c3c8556141313281.txt